Europe 2040: What future for European security?
Geopolitics, Defence, Energy, Climate, Technology, Economy, Society
- -
Welcome and opening address
Welcome
Bernard Magenhann, Chair of ESPAS; Director-General, Joint Research Centre, European Commission
- -
Opening session
Europe 2040: What future for European security?
Victor Negrescu MEP, Vice-President of the European Parliament
Glenn Micallef, European Commissioner for Intergenerational Fairness, Culture, Youth and Sport
Moderator
Bernard Magenhann, Chair of ESPAS; Director-General, Joint Research Centre, European Commission
- -
Keynote Address
Building the capacity to choose Europe’s security future
Europe’s core security challenge is to preserve its freedom of action in a more volatile, transactional world, shaped by hard power, shadow systems, slower growth and technological disruption. Less visible shifts, including the connection of theatres, domestication of foreign policy, uncontrollably powerful tech firms and electrification of the economy deepen uncertainty further. This keynote explores three scenarios for how European security will be organised in the future: around structural dependency, “bilateralisation” or issue-specific sovereignty. To maintain its freedom of manoeuvre, Europe must build an autonomous security architecture, pioneer a new form of multilateralism and nurture a more competitive economic base. Above all, Europe needs greater resilience, optionality and decision-speed so choices are made in Europe, not imposed from Washington, Moscow or Beijing.
Steven Everts, Director, European Union Institute for Security Studies
Moderator
Katarina Engberg, Senior Adviser, Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies (SIEPS)
- -
Coffee
- -
Panel session 1
Future of European security and defence
The shift from cooperation to competition poses critical questions for the EU’s future role on the global stage. Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine threatens Europe’s security. China is challenging Europe geo-economically, weaponising economic and trade dependencies. Security challenges in the EU strategic environment also derive from the erosion of the rules-based international order with a marked shift from rules to power and asymmetrical warfare, as exemplified in the current conflicts in the Middle East, an acceleration away from international cooperation including on new technologies, climate change and trade, and increased maritime, cyber and hybrid threats. At the same time, the United States is in the process of recalibrating its foreign policy priorities and posture and calling on Europe to step up its own defence capabilities. Hard power will increasingly define global security.
What will be the defence and security challenges facing Europe in 2040? How could the European Union defend itself effectively, prepare better, and who could its global partners of choice be?
Mika Aaltola MEP, Member, Foreign Affairs Committee, European Parliament; former Director, Finnish Institute of International Affairs
Peter Engelke, Senior fellow, Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security and the Global Energy Center, Atlantic Council; Founder of the Council’s ‘Global Foresight’ publication
Benedetta Berti, Secretary General of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly
Rachel Ellehuus, Director-General of the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI)
Moderator
Koen Aartsma, Programme Lead Strategic Foresight and Intelligence; Senior Research Fellow, Clingendael Institute
- -
Panel session 2
Future of European security: energy and climate
The 2022 energy crisis showed how dependence on imported fuels translates into geopolitical exposure, price shocks, and economic instability. It also clarified something more constructive: the clean energy transition is not only a climate agenda but part of an economic security strategy. By 2040, electrification, home-grown clean generation, and resilient grids can turn Europe’ energy system from a vulnerability into a source of strategic strength.
Thinking EU climate policy and economic competitiveness and security together could offer a European path to strategic autonomy. This can include decentralised and distributed infrastructure, the use of renewables, a more circular economy and creating partnerships with third countries for energy and industrial production.
What could the synergy between sustainability and economic security in Europe look like by 2040? How can we see competitiveness, affordability, and decarbonisation not as competing goals, but as pointing in the same direction?
Mallika Ishwaran, Group Chief Economist, Shell International
Jean-Marc Jancovici, Founder and President of The Shift Project. Climate change & Energy consultant, author. Co-founder and Partner of Carbone 4
Lola Vallejo, Director, Diplomacy Programme, European Climate Foundation
Albéric Mongrenier, Executive Director, European Initiative for Energy Security
Moderator
Heather Grabbe, Senior Fellow, Bruegel
- -
Lunch
- -
Keynote Address
Destination 2040 – Critical Future Influences Shaping Possible Scenarios and Choices for European Society, Governance, and Security
This session will explore critical factors that could shape the global landscape over the next 15 years. It will highlight the possible choices and challenges that could emerge for Europe’s citizens, societies, businesses, institutions, and government entities and the potential defence and security implication. Across the planet, for citizens, businesses, governments, and global institutions, uncertainty has become the defining characteristic shaping both the current operating environment and the foreseeable future. The interaction between the underlying components of uncertainty has created what many now consider a cascading polycrisis. The resulting complexity means that navigating a path through it requires fundamentally different ways of thinking about the future. It also means evolving how we act to create what we would consider to be positive futures for European citizens and democracies. The landscape of 2040 will be shaped by multiple cycles of change, disruption, and complex interactions between the domains of geopolitics and governance, economics, science, technology, environment, sustainability, and socio-demographics. These in turn will raise both global and local security questions and challengers. Central to this story will be the shift in economic and political power eastwards. China will have completed three five year advancement plan cycles and be embarking on its fourth. India in turn will be to thirds of the way through its journey to fulfil its 2047 development plan. Underlying these future factors will be the pace of development in fields such as the rise of smart money, artificial general intelligence, artificial superintelligence, human enhancement, and the growth of the bio-economy. The range of scenarios that could emerge range from the dystopian to the utopian. The bleaker perspectives are driven by growing evidence of potential existential risks, consolidation of wealth of power, a shift towards autocratic techno-feudalism, and the emergence of non-democratic network states. Deep concerns are already arising emerging over the risk of the total collapse of what are currently considered as weak and failing nations. The more optimistic end of the scenario spectrum offers the potential for human centric techno-progressive advances that harness exponential advances in science and technology. Such advances offer the promise of tackling global grand challenges, creating true resource abundance, and strengthening democracies through digitally enabled deliberative and participative citizen engagement. The presentation will explore how these factors could combine to shape potential scenarios, challenges, choices around strategic direction, and delivery options that could arise for European policy makers. Critical among these policy choices will be the themes of digital sovereignty, technology guardrails, values, societal development, defence and security, Europe’s role in a changing world, and governance at the national, Europe-wide, and institutional levels.
Rohit Talwar, Global Futurist and CEO of Fast Future.
- -
Coffee
- -
Panel session 3
Future of European security: technology and the economy
Economic growth and competitiveness will increasingly be tied to technological leadership and innovation. Europe has strengths in technology but remains too dependent on others for critical technologies. Artificial Intelligence, Quantum and Cyber will be critical to Europe’s future due to their potential to drive productivity, competitiveness and economic growth, and accelerate research, innovation and technological progress. They will also be of growing importance in relation to economic security as those controlling the most advanced technologies and supply chains can concentrate power on an unprecedented scale.
What could the European model of technological power look like in 2040?
How can Europe reduce dangerous dependencies without becoming protectionist? What is a realistic level of technological sovereignty?
Jean-Paul Carvalho, Professor of Political Economy, Department of Economics, University of Oxford
Eugenia Ramírez Reyes Retana, Head of Corporate Strategy, Telefónica
Maria Demertzis, Professor of Economic Policy (part-time), Florence School of Transnational Governance, European University Institute
Étienne Grass, Global Chief AI Officer | Capgemini Invent
Moderator
Paweł Świeboda, Senior Fellow for Technology Policy, European Policy Centre; Senior Fellow for Neurotechnology, Center for Future Generations
- -
Panel session 4
Future of European security: societal resilience
Societies around the world are undergoing transformative change: in the economy and work, technology, climate change, rising inequalities, questions of intergenerational fairness, trust in institutions, and challenges to democracy.
Europe finds itself confronting many of these challenges too. Although they are many and varied, they are all related to the stability of society and social cohesion.
If resilience is the capacity of societies to withstand and adapt to shocks, then reducing poverty and exclusion is not only a social objective but a strategic one. The ESPAS foresight paper "Inclusive futures: ‘Shaping EU pathways out of poverty and social exclusion" explores long-term policy choices for ensuring that all citizens can participate fully in economic, social and democratic life.
What could a stable European society actually look like in 2040? What policy areas should be prioritised to make our societies resilient and more cohesive?
Emil Boc, Mayor of Cluj-Napoca and former Prime Minister of Romania
Viktoriya Podgorna, People’s Deputy (MP), Verkhovna Rada, Ukraine
Elizabeth Kuiper, Associate Director and Head of the Health and Societal Resilience Programme (HSR), European Policy Centre
Gaja Šavelė, Strategic programs and advocacy manager, NGO Coalition, Lithuania
Moderator
Eamonn Noonan, Independent foresight consultant
- -
Closing remarks and takeaways
Bernard Magenhann, Chair of ESPAS; Director-General, Joint Research Centre, European Commission